Pytanie: Karate vs Taekwondo vs Capoeira vs Kick Boxing vs Wrestling vs Boxing vs Kung Fu?

( Wstecz )

Answer #1:

There is no way to say that there is a best, Karate specializes in punches and kicks while Taekwondo kicks, capoeira is more of a dance Kick boxing is more of a muscle fighting technique mostly relying on power. Wrestling is also like Kick Boxing but you pin your opponent down.

Answer #2:

all have good advantages in their own rights. But Wrestling is not the best I think, others have more philosophy. I hate to see people pursuing martial arts just because of strength and violence just because it'll make them look cool, because almost all martial arts philosophy taught us to be calm and peaceful.

Answer #3:

Capoeira is more a brazilian dance. The rest is more self defense i would go with karate because of the belts and it gives you a lot of motivation!

Answer #4:

"Which martial art is the best?"

None.

Answer #5:

There is no "best" martial art as each and every of the styles that exist have their good points and their flaws. For example, taekwondo practitioners have very strong and well developed leg muscles but tend to put their hands down in times of combat as punches to the opponent's head are forbidden in our sparring matches. Another one would be boxing. No leg contact is allowed in boxing but students of their art have some of the strongest arms in any martial arts.

Answer #6:

which one is the best, is more of a question of which one is best for me based on these preferences.. since you didn't list any preferences the practitioner who loses in any of these matches is the one who wasn't trained well, or goofed off and didn't dedicate himself to his art..

however, If I asked, "which martial art should I do because I like grappling?" (as an example, I don't know exactly what style I prefer.) Someone probably would not answer Savate, cause there isn't much grappling in it.. they would answer BJJ/JJJ or Sambo, or catch wrestling even, but I would avoid suggesting striking styles or hybrid styles.

by the way Capoeira is a martial art, the slaves in Brazil mixed their techniques with dance moves so they could practice without the Brazilians recognizing it.. after slavery was banned the Brazilians started learning it cause they thought it was good/cool/fun.

Answer #7:

You say you are a TKD practitioner since 1995 yet you ask what MA is the best? Surely if you have been doing MAs that long you would understand that there is no "best" MA.

Answer #8:

Karate is clearly better as it provides self defence, taekwondo is just all about the kicking and attacking, kickboxing is almost karate don't know what capoeira is wrestling is people practically killing each other, boxing is just punching, kung fu is like a mix of all of them i think.
so karate is the best!!!!

Answer #9:

There is no 'best' martial art. An art is a collection of philosophies, principles of movement, and techniques; you can't really compare one to another. It's the individual quality of practitioners that you might be able to judge.

And even if there was one - if there was one martial art that was universally regarded as "more effective" than other arts, you can't expect that every single school that teaches it can uphold the same level of quality in their training...

Answer #10:

Since all martial arts are "arts", and boxing and wrestling are sports, they all have their own rules and philosophical objectives.

In this regard, none are "best" just as tennis and badminton with different rules and objectives cannot be comparatively measured other than in an objective sense of personal preference.

However, if you ask which is the most effective or practical, I think the answer is clearer. Police forces and the military in the west tend to favour boxing and wrestling. These is less ceremony, more sparring, and a more direct and practical approach.

(The average person can become quite proficient in boxing with only six months training and a few months of sparring).

Of course, pacific rim countries with a tradition of karate and judo will opt for these versions of striking and wrestling.

The simpler the style, the quicker the learning curve, and the more likely it might actually be of some use.

Still, in a sporting match, each style is superior in its own dojo/arena/venue as each has different rules. (The tennis pro cannot defeat a badminton pro if both compete in a badminton match.).

But, the tennis pro will win in a duel, as the tennis racquet is heavier. (HYAHHH! .....thud).

Answer #11:

Oh for god's sake, there is no definitive way to compare martial arts. Sure you can get top practitioners of said arts to fight but it won't decide anything, one could genetically better at fighting than the other. Stop with these ridiculous questions. If you have practiced TKD for 15 years I would have expected more of you

Answer #12:

I think that TAE kwon doe is the best but you may not, remember it was also bruce lees favourute type aswell, bu again your opinion may diiffer, it also dpends what your favouite films were slash are.





** Powered by Yahoo Answers